top of page
  • Writer's pictureTeresa Yanaros

8 Arguments for Roman Catholicism by John Henry Newman

John Henry Newman was a prominent 19th-century Anglican priest and theologian who later converted to Roman Catholicism.

John Henry Newman

John Henry Newman, a Theologian

His writings and teachings had a profound influence on individuals who chose to leave the Anglican Church and join the Roman Catholic Church.

Here are some of the key teachings of Newman that influenced this decision:

  1. Development of Doctrine: Newman proposed the idea that Christian doctrine is not static, but develops over time in response to changing circumstances and understanding. This concept was seen as supportive of the Roman Catholic Church's claim to possess an unbroken continuity with the early Church.

  2. Authority and Infallibility: Newman emphasized the need for a visible, authoritative Church to interpret Scripture and guide believers. He argued that the Roman Catholic Church, with its central authority in the Pope, provided a more secure foundation for Christian faith and practice.

  3. The Church as a Teacher: Newman stressed the importance of a teaching authority within the Church, capable of defining and safeguarding core Christian doctrines. He believed that the Roman Catholic Church fulfilled this role more effectively than the Anglican Church.

  4. Papal Infallibility: Newman's teachings paved the way for acceptance of the doctrine of papal infallibility, which was declared a dogma of the Roman Catholic Church at the First Vatican Council in 1870. This teaching asserts that under certain conditions, the Pope is preserved from error when making pronouncements on matters of faith and morals.

  5. Historical Continuity: Newman argued that the Roman Catholic Church had maintained an unbroken historical continuity with the early Christian Church, emphasizing the importance of apostolic succession and the preservation of ancient traditions.

  6. The Via Media Critique: Newman critiqued the Anglican notion of the "Via Media" (middle way) between Roman Catholicism and Protestantism. He argued that the Anglican Church's position was unstable and lacked the theological coherence and historical continuity found in Roman Catholicism.

  7. The "Illative Sense": Newman introduced the concept of the "illative sense," which referred to an intuitive grasp of truth based on accumulated evidence and reason. This was seen as supporting the idea that a rational examination of historical and theological evidence could lead to the conclusion that the Roman Catholic Church was the true Church.

  8. The Role of Conscience: Newman highlighted the importance of an informed and well-formed conscience in matters of faith and obedience. He believed that the Roman Catholic Church provided a clear moral framework and authoritative guidance for individuals to follow their conscience.

Instrumental Teachings

Newman's writings, particularly his "Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine" and his autobiographical work "Apologia Pro Vita Sua," were instrumental in shaping the intellectual and theological climate of his time.

They played a significant role in leading many individuals, including clergy and academics, to choose the Roman Catholic Church over the Anglican Church during the 19th century.


Spirit Sanctified educates Christians on spiritual warfare through multi-media productions and products. We comprise advocates, creators, and deliverance ministers who work together to help Christians stand against occult worldviews by purifying their beliefs and practices.

The above article may contain affiliate links. You are not required to use these links, but if you use any of them to make a purchase, Spirit Sanctified makes a small monetary return at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support!

This article appeared first on Spirit Sanctified. This article (8 Arguments for Roman Catholicism by John Henry Newman) on Spirit Sanctified and is free and open source. You have permission to share or republish this article in full so long as attribution to the author and Spirit Sanctified are provided.

bottom of page